Cashflow Analysis

EBITDA is NOT cash flow

  • EBITDA is used in commonly used ratios such as DSC (EBITDA/CPLTD) and leverage (debt/EBITDA),  but it does not capture key items such as interest, taxes, working capital and capital expenditures that affect a company’s cash flow
  • EBITDA – Taxes – Increase in NWC – Capex – Other operating investments = Free Cash flow available for debt service
  • To calculate DSC,
    • Make adjustments to current cash + expected incoming + expected outgoing
    • Expected outgoing expenses (how elastic are these expenses. Non- discretionary and inelastic)
    • Equity injection (personal equity) – See promoters’ track records in terms of how willing he is to fund

PD Analysis: EBITDA =/= CASHFLOW

Adjustments to Financial Statements

Moody’s adjustments to financial statements

  1. Defined benefit pensions
  2. Operating leases (off-BS, only lease expense on P/L)
  3. Finance leases
  4. Capitalised interest
  5. Capitalised development cost –> MOST IMPORTANT
    Capex
    Planned
    – Maintenance (hard to reduce, depends on elasticity)
    – Incremental (may be reduced)
    Committed
    – Timing
    – Financial Consequences (break cost)
    3 sources of finding out planned and committed capex
    – Regulatory requirement for management disclosure
    – Analysts own estimates (Eg. taxi companies need to replace after 10 years)
    – Ask customer (RM’s call report)
  6. Interest expense related to discounted LT liabilities other than debt
  7. Hybrid securities
  8. Securitisation
  9. Inventory on a LIFO cost basis
  10. Consistent measurement of funds from operations – different measures of working capital
  11. Unusual and non-recurring items
  12. Unusually large transactions (creating revenue, costs or cash flows) that management does not expect to recur in the foreseeable future
  13. Other analytical non-standard adjustments

** DETERMINE IF THESE ADJUSTMENTS ARE MATERIAL RELATIVE TO EQUITY BUFFER
Why equity buffer? Because it affects D/E ratio which can change the credit rating

Dividends – In Cash VS Shares

The “Ideal” Balance Sheet

  • Cash conversion on the asset side is exactly matched with repayment cycle on the liabilities side
  • Current ratio is not useful because it ignores maturity mismatches within the 1 year bucket
  • Some current assets may have to move down the pyramid
    • Eg. Obsolete Inventory, Imparied AR, etc
    • Even cash is not always immediately available (eg. cash in different currency or location or units)
  • Long term liabilities may come due immediately
    • If a ST trade creditor sue, other loans may come due immediately
    • Covenant and credit events
    • Bullet repayment

What is the adjusted equity buffer?

  • Overvalued assets (involving non-market valuation)
    • Intangibles (e.g. brands or goodwill)
    • Inventory (e.g. biological assets)
    • Land and properties (less of a concern in SG)
  • Accounts receivables
    • RP balances vs. RP transactions (elasticity)
    • Island debtors
    • Types of concentration risks
  • Irretrievable assets (T&C risk)
  • Contingent liabilities/ hidden liabilities à more likely to crystallize at declining stage
    • Warranty obligations or anticipated litigation loss
    • Environmental/ third party claims, e.g. kampong head
    • Labour union claims under negotiation
    • Operating leases
  • Liabilities disguised as equity: substance over form, when is the repayment date?
    • Perpetual preference stocks
    • Strategic vs. financial investors (e.g. SME – “friend’s investment”)
  • Pension obligations (increase discount rate for NPV calculation)

Other Practical Considerations

SME Free flow of capital between natural and legal entity

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *